Wednesday, February 19, 2014

POLICE BRUTALITY-A CAVEAT OF JUSTICE (c) 2014 by Wayne Dan Lewis, Sr.


America’s Black Eye on Civil Rights

AMERICA FOUGHT FOR ITS CIVIL RIGHTS-For many citizens of America, whenever the term Civil Rights is referenced, it may bring images of Black people stirring up trouble in America.  It appears that any reference to Civil Rights causes many other American citizens to run the other way, irrespective of the fact that the rights that Blacks fought for, and continue to fight for, and are gradually loosing, are just as important to the greater population as it is to People of Color.  In the commemoration of Black History, we often want to speak to the achievements of those who have contributed to the greatness that is America, who, but for the fact that they were of color, were strategically overlooked, or disregarded for their contributions.

When we speak of Civil Rights and Black History, it would appear as though Blacks were/are the only class of people who fought/fight for Civil Rights. How soon America forgets when this country was reportedly founded on the basis of Civil Rights in its breaking away from Great Britain.  So, when People of Color fought for their Civil Rights, after the first violation of their initial Civil Rights through slavery, the idea that former slaves would be benefiting from America’s hard-fought achievement in the breaking away from Great Britain, would seem to have been a no-brainer, in theory, per the Constitution of the United States, where all people, are created equal, regardless of race, creed or color, and are entitled to their Civil Rights.  Well, not so fast!  Send in the police!

BLACKS STILL FIGHT FOR CIVIL RIGHTS-In this annual recognition of Black History, 2014BHR, it would seem that we would be re-missed if we did not discuss, in brief, the role that our police agencies have played, and continue to play regarding the importance of Civil Rights for all Americans.  America’s history, with respect to People of Color’s fight for Civil Rights, will no doubt, be gradually altered, and will hardly reflect on the role that police officers played in the denial of Civil Rights, based on race.  Through the years, as America’s remaining history may show, police officers were used by governmental entities to ensure that People of Color could not have access to the most basic of needs (water from a fountain, bathrooms, sitting on a bus, or eating in restaurants).  Thank God, those days are no longer in play, theoretically.  But there is still a problem, and here it is:  Police Brutality.

PROCEDURAL INJUSTICE-Police departments have for so long been practically given complete autonomy in the role of suppressing People of Color’s intent to secure Civil Rights, that now it appears to be procedural policies, throughout our nation.  In furtherance of that autonomy, Police Officers act as their own justice system to investigate, and to hold accountable, where applicable, those officers who are accused of misbehavior as law enforcement officers.  It appears to be so procedural, that District Attorneys are slow to press charges against our police officers, necessitating, where financially possible, for citizens to seek justice outside of their communities.  Police Brutality appears to be so procedural, that practically any exchange between police officers and People of Color could result in an unintended consequence of up to and including, what would have been just an arrest on any given day, deadly force for many of People of Color’s sons.  And more often than not, it is deemed to be justified.  Where possible, and often immediately available, the victim’s police record, however slight (stopped for speeding, disturbing the peace), or great (juvenile detention 20 years prior, burglary conviction, 10 years prior) becomes the first justification of dismissiveness towards the value of their lives.  Whether by intent or design, it appears that the constant loss of lives of at the hands of police officers throughout America is procedural, and seemingly, insignificant when it comes to young men of color.

“I FEARED FOR MY LIFE”-Police Brutality has taken a new low in Black History, and while many of us will sit idly by while it continues to weave itself in and out of the Criminal Justice System or the Federal Justice System, we can take solace in the fact that all previous efforts to acquire full Civil Rights are like Elvis (Presley), and that is, those rights have just about left the building.  To all of our Political leaders, whomever you are, please, remain quiet, as many of our police officers appear to be more armed than ever with full malice, and will hereby be justified in their course of action when the life of an unarmed Black male is taken. Vis-a-vie:  “I feared for my life!” 

“I feared for my life”, will continue to be the rallying cry for many of our police officers, whether the suspect is armed, thought to be armed, or thinking about being armed.  “I feared for my life” will be the measure of justice more often than not, for young black male victims, shot to death more frequently as a result of lawfully approved actions of “stop and frisk”, that all too often, go wrong.  Many of our Black males are shot to death, irrespective of their GPA or their volunteer status.  Black males, all too often are shot to death, irrespective of their fatherly status, their collegiate status, their financial status, or better yet, their innocent status.   This measure of justice, even when reasonably justified, will eventually be the measure of the entire law enforcement community. Where potentially for all of our police officers, anything, or anyone that moves, maybe cause to shoot to kill, and the defining defense will be from this day forth:  “I feared for my life”. 

LET’S NOT BE CONFUSED-Let us not confuse Crime fighting with the suppression of Civil Rights.  The two are distinctly different, and here is how:  Crime fighting activities place many of our police officers at risk of their lives, everyday, from the moment they wear the uniform.  At any minute, they could be put into a life or death situation, and when their training kicks in, they will be trusted to act according to that training, regardless of the perpetrator’s background, race, creed or color. 

Conversely, the suppression or denial of anyone’s Civil Rights, is a violation of the United States Constitution.  When a police officer or any member of the Criminal Justice Division of our country, uses its office to exercise hatred by denying any reasonable action in the name of the law, we have a violation of Civil Rights. When an officer suspends the vital training that they are believed to be fortified from their departments, and acts above the law for their own agenda, crime fighting is no longer an issue.

ALTERNATIVES TO POLICE BRUTALITY- There are alternatives to Police Brutality and the reputation that it imposes on the police agencies and many of the great and honorable police officers who swore to protect and to serve their communities.  But our cities and our governments are content to allow a select few officers to bust their budgets, investigating “bad shoots”, and/or civil lawsuits against accusations of Police Brutality, rather than doing more to fully screen for police officers whose agendas seek to satisfy hatred,  instead of building positive community relations within all communities.  But to take that approach by our local, state and federal governments would suggest that Civil Rights is too valuable a commodity to allow for all of their citizens to enjoy, so let those who best exemplify the underlying intent to suppress Civil Rights, roam free, and do so as they will, armed with their rallying cry:  “I feared for my life!” 

TO PROTECT TO SERVE-To the many fine officers who so nobly wear the badge throughout our various communities, continue to stand down, while those among you take aim, not just at the bodies that are of color, but subsequently, at the Civil Rights of all Americans.  Many of those Americans are your families, interracially, by blood, by marriage, by religion, by communities, by fraternities or sororities, and if by nothing else, by God.  To those of you who are police officers, who are above the dishonoring of your Sworn Oaths, you have as much of an obligation to stand toe-to-toe with the injustices from within your departments, as quickly as you are to take down the criminals on the street who just stole that little old-lady’s purse.  Otherwise, it will be you, their fellow officers, who will suffer at the hands of rogue officers who will tarnish not only the badges that you wear so proudly, but the honor that you share in being men and women who swore “To Protect and Serve”.

CAVEATS OF JUSTICE ©[i]- The only problem with the oath of office of many of our police officers today and going forward, is that those sworn oaths now come with a caveat.  That caveat is “To Protect and Serve”, a select few.  That caveat is “To Protect and Serve”, those whom we deem are worthy United States citizens.  That caveat is “To Protect and Serve”, to the highest bidder.  And because of these caveats, whether procedural or intentional, our communities will continue to be divided along racial lines, religious lines, sexual orientation lines, party lines, class lines and whatever lines can be drawn with respect to Civil Rights, with our Police Departments serving loyally as defenders against crime, and vanguards for violations of Civil Rights.  The only difference between those lines now is that Police Brutality poses as an acknowledged and acceptable way of life for many of our police officers who would otherwise sought to wear their uniforms with pride and honor. But now, for those hard working officers, who put themselves in harm’s way on any given day, this caveat gives the impression that our police officers are just doing a job, and are just getting a paycheck.  That with this caveat of justice, many of our police officers and police departments, are wearing a black-eye, all across America.  

As long as our political and police leaders turn a blind eye to the suppression of Civil Rights of People of Color or anyone for that matter, the badges that so many of our men and women wear so proudly, will be the least of which to tarnish.  For those of our officers who are within the ranks of our local, state and federal law enforcement agencies, you, with your various years of outstanding service, if your service has any real value, you will take this time to remove this caveat of justice.  For our political leaders, many of whom your children are just as likely to fall prey to this new found rallying cry: “I feared for my life”, this is your opportunity to live up to your sworn oath as leaders, by standing up for those who rely on police officers to not only protect them from crime, but to protect them from the injustices of those who swore before God, to uphold the law.   

If this is too much to ask of our leaders, then allow Police Brutality to remain the caveat of justice within the Black Community.  Allow it to continue to fester, and to swell.  Allow this caveat of justice to become infected, and to continue to grow from within the ranks of our local, state and federal agencies.  If this is too much to ask of our city, state and federal leaders to remove this caveat of justice, then allow this black-eye to remain within law enforcement agencies from arrests to deadly force; through its recruitment programs; from cadets to patrolmen; from the training that our officers receive to internal affairs and their self-investigations; from the desk sergeants to watch commanders, as well as each rank within our agencies to our police chiefs, sheriffs, Commanders and Directors of every law enforcement agency throughout America, allow this caveat of justice to remain well placed, well developed, and a real shiner on those who are truly committed  “To Protect and Serve”.   And if it this is too much to ask to remove Police Brutality as a caveat of justice here in America, then it is essentially allowing the bullies of (in)justice to operate peacefully, under the color of law.  


[i] Caveat(s) of Justice © 2014 by Wayne Dan Lewis, Sr. and The Coveted Commandment © 2014 by Wayne Dan Lewis, Sr.